01/10/2026
AMA Tasmania president, GP Dr Meg Creely, told The Medical Republic that she felt the evaluation was incomplete. “It doesn’t say ‘does this reduce healthcare costs?’, ‘does this reduce pressure on general practice?’ – the one thing it does tell us is that the incredibly small portion of patients surveyed, liked it,” Dr Creely said.
“To me, this just isn’t a report.” Dr Creely acknowledged that the state government had already put a significant amount of money toward funding the trial, having agreed to reimburse pharmacists at $20 per consultation.
With over 6534 episodes of care delivered over the course of the trial, the cost to the government was $130,680 in services alone – not including costs related to administration, training, or marketing. When asked whether that sunk cost may have made it harder for the state government to walk away from the trial, Dr Creely said there were other approaches that were still open to the government.
“In a state which doesn’t have a lot of money and is making cuts in many places, I think investing that money was the wrong idea,” she said.
“But I think if there’s two choices, and one is to walk away from a bad decision so as to not create harm, and the other is to keep going ahead with it despite a lack of evaluation and a lack of evidence – then I think, from a patient safety perspective, the right call is to walk away from it and regroup.
“Look at what the evidence tells us works well, particularly our patients in Tasmania who have high rates of chronic and complex disease, often multiple of those.
“We know that having pharmacists within general practice will give those patients better care if we can use both the skills of the GP and the pharmacist to manage their chronic and complex care. That’s what we know works.
“I completely agree that spending however many millions of dollars we’re up to now, has been done. But I think this is a ‘cut your losses and move on’ rather than continuing down a pathway.
“Certainly, of the 23 proposed new protocols we’ve just seen land, there’s a huge amount of work in there. It creates transactional care. Patients don’t just walk into general practice with hypertension alone, or really any of those chronic conditions alone.”
It’s a not-so-logical sequence of events, say both the RACGP and the AMA Tasmania.