30/09/2026
Richard Asher (1912-1969) was a
British physician, teacher, and medical writer admired for his wit, clear thinking, and deep concern for patients. He challenged accepted medical habits and championed simplicity in communication. As a physician, I find his writings a lasting reminder that knowledge must be accompanied by judgment, humility, and compassion. His "Seven Sins of Medicine,"
Published in 1949, still invite every doctor to reflect on how we practise.
SEVEN SINS OF MEDICINE
Reflections on Richard Asher’s enduring wisdom
As a physician, I have long admired Richard Asher for his clarity, humanity, and willingness to question medical habits. His “Seven Sins of Medicine,” published in The Lancet in 1949, remain remarkably relevant today.
Here is my interpretation of his message for modern practice:
1. Obscurity
Explain clearly. Medical knowledge should help patients understand, rather than leave them intimidated by jargon.
2. Cruelty
Be thoughtful with words and interventions. Honest conversations require compassion, and every investigation should have a meaningful purpose.
3. Bad manners
Listen patiently and treat patients, families, nurses, and colleagues with respect. Courtesy is part of clinical competence.
4. Over-specialisation
Develop expertise without losing sight of the whole person. Patients’ needs extend beyond the boundaries of our specialties.
5. Love of the rare
Consider uncommon diagnoses, but keep probability in perspective. An intriguing diagnosis is not necessarily the most likely one.
6. Common stupidity
Avoid treating by habit. Evidence and guidelines are essential, but their application requires judgment and attention to the individual patient.
7. Sloth
Remain curious and thorough. Examine, question, reassess, and keep learning. Neither a previous diagnosis nor an AI-generated answer should replace independent thought.
For me, Asher’s message is a reminder that progress in medicine must include progress in how we listen, think, explain, and care.
Technology expands what we can do. Wisdom helps us decide what we should do—and compassion guides how we do it.
Dr. Benny Panakkal
Inspired by: Asher R. The seven sins of medicine. The Lancet. 1949;2(6574):358–360.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(49)90090-2