07/10/2026
What would you treat first?
On examination you find:
Localized heat and inflammation
Sharp, stabbing pain
Pain rated 8–9/10
Movement aggravates the pain
At first glance, it seems straightforward.
But during your intake, you also discover that they:
Are always cold
Have an aversion to cold weather
Prefer warm drinks and soups
Urinate frequently with clear urine
Feel tired most of the time
Describe themselves as mentally "flat"
Would you focus primarily on the acute excess presentation—the inflammation and severe pain?
Or would you also address the underlying deficiency that seems to be influencing the person's overall health?
After nearly 30 years of practice and teaching, I've found that this is where clinical reasoning becomes far more important than technique.
Many practitioners are excellent with their hands. The real challenge is knowing what the body is asking for before deciding how to treat it.
I'm curious how you would approach this case, and more importantly, why.
I'd love to hear your clinical reasoning.