17/09/2026
New Episode! "Are We Our Own Worst Enemy? Self-Talk, Peer Support & the Stories We Tell Ourselves"
After getting some constructive criticism about negative self-talk on a previous episode, Elliott and Billy dig into the difference between negativity, self-doubt, and simply being realistic. Can recognizing that something is going to be difficult actually help prepare you for it? And when does realistic self-talk cross the line into something that holds you back?
The conversation moves into law enforcement, where mindset, training, confidence, and the stories we tell ourselves can have real consequences. After a difficult call, first responders may have the facts—but the mind can keep digging, filling in unanswered questions and creating a story around what happened. Sometimes, having everything you need means allowing the facts to simply be the facts.
Elliott and Billy also discuss peer support after critical incidents and the role supervisors and command staff play in making it accessible. Instead of asking an officer, “Do you want peer support?” and putting the decision on them in the moment, maybe leadership should simply set it up, make it available, and then get out of the way.
And somehow, all of that leads exactly where you would expect a Maine Responder conversation to go: Tom Selleck, old-school cop mustaches, questionable modern mustaches, and the possibility of a Maine Responder mustache challenge.
In this episode:
• Negative self-talk vs. realistic self-assessment
• Confidence, self-doubt, and preparing for challenges
• How training builds genuine confidence
• The stories first responders can create around difficult calls
• Knowing when to stop searching for an answer that may not exist
• Peer support following critical incidents
• Why supervisors may need to simply set it up and step aside
• Building peer support into agency culture
• The return of the mustache
• Billy is going to grow one
Conversations about the work, the pressure, and the lives shaped by service.
Maine Responder Podcast
After getting some constructive criticism about negative self-talk on a previous episode, Elliott and Billy dig into the difference between negativity, self-doubt, …